From the French court to the artisan
Top of Page
The transition from the French court's highly formal, aristocratic traditions to a more vibrant, artisan-driven cultural shift, particularly through the lens of Nicola Matteis’ "Aria Burlesca", makes perfect sense when viewed in this context.
During the late 17th century, there was indeed a significant shift happening across Europe. In France, the court of Louis XIV set the standard for highly formalized, hierarchical culture, particularly through the Académie system, which prized refinement, control, and grandeur. French court music under composers like Jean-Baptiste Lully was disciplined and structured, embodying the power of the monarchy and the upper echelons of society.
Contrast this with the Italian influence that Matteis brought to England—one that was more closely connected to the artisans, merchants, and a growing middle class. Italian music during this time was marked by its virtuosity, emotional expressiveness, and a certain informal energy that would have seemed more vibrant and freewheeling in comparison to the rigidity of French court music. In Italy, musicians and composers were often seen as skilled craftsmen, closely connected to the artisan class, rather than just serving in noble courts. This artisan-driven movement embraced creativity, improvisation, and technical showmanship, aligning with Matteis’ style.
The "Aria Burlesca" can be seen as encapsulating this very transition. If the opening feels claustrophobic and tightly controlled, it may represent the formal constraints of the French court and its highly refined, ornamental music. As the piece “spirals out of control” and embraces the "pure italiana" style, it could symbolize the shift toward a more artisan-driven culture, where music was no longer just the domain of the elite, but a vibrant, emotional expression of broader society. The lively, unpredictable nature of the burlesca could be a nod to the growing influence of the middle class and the artisan spirit, as these new musical forms broke away from the overly structured, courtly traditions.
Matteis, in many ways, was a bridge between these worlds. He brought the Italian bel canto and virtuosic violin traditions, often associated with the streets and public performances, to the more formalized English musical scene, which had been influenced by both French and German traditions. His ability to blend these elements—artistic spontaneity with technical brilliance—mirrors the broader cultural transitions happening across Europe at the time. This shift from the refined world of the French court to the more dynamic, expressive world of the artisan is perfectly reflected in how his Aria Burlesca might unfold.
I misspoke with 'spirals out of control' it just does what it wants
Ah, I see! So instead of "spiraling out of control," the "Aria Burlesca" is more about the music freely following its own course, expressing autonomy and fluidity. That makes even more sense in terms of the broader cultural shift from the formal constraints of the French court to the more spontaneous, expressive style of the Italian artisan culture.
This idea of the music "doing what it wants" reflects the more liberated, improvisatory nature of Italian music at the time, where composers like Matteis embraced a freer form of expression, less bound by the formalities and restrictions that might have governed the music of the French aristocracy. The burlesca element, often humorous and light-hearted, allows for playfulness and unpredictability, which suits this interpretation perfectly.
In this way, the "Aria Burlesca" becomes not a descent into chaos but an embodiment of a new kind of freedom—one where the music flows organically, unrestricted by the rigid frameworks of the past, reflecting the broader cultural evolution towards individuality and artisan creativity.
Well it just becomes more natural, more rustic, more Italian
That makes perfect sense—the transition into something more natural, rustic, and Italian speaks directly to the cultural shift you’re describing. The move away from the highly stylized and formal French court toward a more grounded, earthy, and authentic expression would reflect the essence of Italian artistic culture during Matteis' time.
Italian music of the period often celebrated the raw beauty of nature and the human spirit, embracing simplicity and a certain rustic charm, while maintaining technical brilliance. In this way, the "Aria Burlesca" would symbolize not just a stylistic shift, but a deeper cultural move towards a more organic, less contrived expression of artistry. This rustic, more "Italian" style captures the essence of Italy's artisan-driven culture—where creativity and spontaneity flow more naturally, rooted in everyday life rather than aristocratic pomp.